On this page · 5 sections
Some colleges call a supplemental essay optional. Of the 40 colleges whose 2026-27 supplements we have copied from their own admissions pages, 13 have at least one such question: 11 where the writing is optional for everyone, and 2 where it applies only if you list a second or alternate major.
Every question and limit below comes from each college's own page, checked on 26 October 2026. We report the wording each college uses. Where a college says an essay is "recommended" or "encouraged", the table says so, because that is not the same as plain optional.
The 13 colleges and what is optional at each
| College | What is optional | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Duke University | One of three: viewpoints and experiences, a difference of opinion, or something you are excited about | up to 250 words |
| Northwestern University | Five questions; the college encourages at least one and no more than two | 200 words each |
| California Institute of Technology | Your academic context (the page says Caltech cares about context) | no limit printed |
| Wake Forest University | A written supplement: one of four, including two list questions | 150 or 300 words; the two list questions print no limit |
| The University of Texas at Austin | Special circumstances that may have affected your academic performance | up to 300 words |
| Bowdoin College | Two essays, both optional | up to 250 words each |
| Washington and Lee University | "Why W&L?", plus one short-answer option | 250 words each; the short answer can also be a 2-minute video |
| Grinnell College | Background and the common good (optional, but recommended) | 200-450 words |
| Macalester College | Two optional prompts: the Twin Cities, and the college's mission | no limit printed |
| Occidental College | A short statement on why Occidental | up to 250 words |
| Fordham University | One short response from three questions | up to 300 words |
| University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign | Only if you apply with a second-choice major | up to 150 words |
| Purdue University | Only if you select an alternate major | up to 250 words |
The last two are not optional in the usual sense: you write them if you choose a second or alternate major. Limits are what each college's page said on the day we checked. Confirm the final limit and the exact wording in the application.
What the list tells you
- 13 of 40 colleges have one, so the other 27 have no question marked optional in our data. Treat their questions as part of the application.
- At 5 of the 11 fully optional colleges (Duke, Wake Forest, Washington and Lee, Fordham, Northwestern) you choose from a set of questions rather than answering one fixed question.
- Optional questions come in every type: why this college (Occidental, Macalester, Washington and Lee), background (Duke, Grinnell, Bowdoin), academic context (Caltech, Texas) and lists (Wake Forest).
- Two colleges use softer words than plain optional: Grinnell calls its prompt optional but recommended, and Northwestern encourages applicants to answer at least one. Read those as the college telling you it reads them.
How to decide whether to write an optional essay
Nothing in the college pages we read says what happens to applicants who skip an optional essay, so we make no claim about that. Ask the admissions office if you are unsure.
- 1Read the college's own sentence. "Optional" alone is a different signal from "optional but recommended" or "we encourage you to answer".
- 2Ask what it would add. Duke's page says to answer if it adds something meaningful that is not already addressed elsewhere in your application. Apply that test to any college: would a reader learn something new about you?
- 3Use the context questions for context. Caltech's and Texas's questions exist for academic circumstances or events that affected your performance. If nothing applies, there is nothing to write.
- 4Do not write one just to fill space. A generic answer to a "why us" question tells a reader less than no answer, so write it only if you can name specifics at that college.
- 5If you do write it, give it the same care as a required essay: the same checks on the exact question, the same word limit and the same honest, specific detail.
Before you submit
Check each answer against the question's exact wording and the limit shown in the application, which can differ from what a college's page said in October. We never write or rewrite an answer for you.
You can have a college's full set of supplemental answers reviewed in one report: choose the college on the supplemental essays page, paste your answers and get feedback on each in 5 to 10 minutes. A supplement token is $4.99.
Questions
A full review: a score out of 100, a note on every sentence, the paragraph costing you most and a 10-point draft check, in 5–10 minutes. We never write a word of your essay.
Review my essay →Keep reading
More in Supplements and UC
All guides by topic →- How to write the "Why this college?" essay2 min
- UC Personal Insight Questions: how to choose and answer them2 min
- How to write the community essay2 min
- How to write the diversity essay3 min
- How to write the "Why this major?" essay5 min
- How to write the extracurricular activity essay4 min
- How to write a scholarship essay4 min
- College short answer questions: how to make 25 to 150 words count3 min
- How to write a college transfer essay3 min
- Can you change your UC application after you submit it?5 min
- UC PIQ 1: how to answer the leadership question6 min
- UC PIQ 8: what makes you a strong candidate for the University of California6 min
- UC PIQ 2: how to answer the creative side question6 min
- UC PIQ 3: how to answer the greatest talent or skill question5 min
- UC PIQ 4: how to answer the educational opportunity or barrier question6 min
- UC PIQ 5: how to answer the significant challenge question6 min
- UC PIQ 6: how to answer the academic subject that inspires you6 min
- UC PIQ 7: how to answer the make your community better question5 min
- Colleges with a "why us" supplemental essay in 2026-27: the list and the word limits5 min
- The 11 types of supplemental essay prompts: what 40 colleges ask in 2026-274 min
- Community supplemental essays in 2026-27: 16 questions at 14 colleges4 min
- Background and identity supplemental essays in 2026-27: 25 questions at 23 colleges5 min
- "What excites you" supplemental essays in 2026-27: 21 questions at 17 colleges4 min
- "A time you disagreed" supplemental essays in 2026-27: 10 questions at 10 colleges4 min
- Creative and unusual supplemental essay prompts in 2026-27: 15 questions at 9 colleges4 min
- "Tell us about an activity" supplemental essays in 2026-27: 7 questions at 7 colleges4 min