On this page · 6 sections
A disagreement question asks what you do when someone sees an issue differently from you. Of the 40 colleges whose 2026-27 supplements we have copied from their own admissions pages, 10 ask one, and each college asks only one.
Every question and limit below comes from each college's own page, checked on 26 October 2026. We sorted each question by what it really asks: seven ask about a specific disagreement or a viewpoint different from yours, and three ask about working or engaging across differences more broadly. Confirm the final wording and limit in the application before you write.
The 10 questions and how long each can be
| College | The question, in short | Limit |
|---|---|---|
| Harvard University | A time you strongly disagreed with someone about an idea or issue | up to 150 words |
| Yale University | An issue important to you, discussed with someone holding an opposing view | up to 400 words (one of several options) |
| Columbia University | A time you did not agree with someone, and how you engaged | up to 150 words |
| Dartmouth College | A difficult conversation, or someone with a different perspective (Jane Goodall) | up to 250 words (one of several options) |
| Duke University | A difference of opinion with someone you care about | up to 250 words (optional, one of three) |
| Johns Hopkins University | What you have learned about engaging across differences | up to 350 words |
| Barnard College | A woman with a different approach who brings people together | 200-250 words |
| Wellesley College | Working alongside people of different backgrounds or perspectives | 250-400 words |
| Amherst College | Engaging with a viewpoint different from your own | up to 350 words (one of several options) |
| Claremont McKenna College | A change of mind through engaging with someone (Open Academy) | no limit printed: use the limit in your application |
Limits are what each college's page said on the day we checked. Yale, Dartmouth and Amherst offer this as one choice among several, and Duke's set is optional, so at those four colleges you can pick another question. Harvard, Columbia, Johns Hopkins, Barnard, Wellesley and Claremont McKenna list it with no choice group in our data.
What the list tells you
- 10 of 40 colleges ask one, so a single honest account of a disagreement can be adapted for several applications. Rebuild the opening each time, because each question is worded differently.
- The limits are short. Of the 9 questions with a limit, 5 allow 250 words or fewer, and the shortest are 150 words (Harvard and Columbia). The longest allow 400 (Yale and Wellesley).
- Seven questions ask about one specific disagreement or different viewpoint. Three (Johns Hopkins, Barnard, Wellesley) ask more broadly about engaging or working across differences, so they accept a longer experience, not one argument.
- Dartmouth and Columbia both name a community or a thinker in the prompt, and Claremont McKenna's question comes with a preamble about its Open Academy commitments. Read the whole prompt, because the opening lines often tell you what the college values.
What a strong answer shows
Our review checks three things beyond answering the exact question.
- A real difference: a specific issue and a specific person or group, with the other side described fairly.
- How you engaged: what you asked, listened to, said and did. Winning the argument is not the point, and you do not need to be the hero.
- What you learned: an honest account of what changed in your thinking or in how you talk with people now, even if neither of you changed your mind.
Choosing the experience
- Pick an issue you can explain in two sentences without a lecture. If the topic needs a paragraph of background, the word limit will be spent before you reach the lesson.
- Pick a disagreement with someone who matters, such as a friend, a teammate, a relative or a teacher. Duke asks for exactly that, and the stakes make your listening visible.
- Avoid the debate you won and the person who turned out to be wrong. Readers see that structure often, and it shows less than a moment where you had to change how you spoke or what you assumed.
- Keep it different from your personal essay. The supplement should add a side of you the main essay does not, such as how you handle conflict.
- At the 150-word colleges, use one exchange, not the whole story. A single moment you can describe in detail beats a summary of weeks of tension.
Before you submit
Check each answer against the question's exact wording and the limit shown in the application, which can differ from what a college's page said in October. We never write or rewrite an answer for you.
You can have a college's full set of supplemental answers reviewed in one report: choose the college on the supplemental essays page, paste your answers and get feedback on each in 5 to 10 minutes. A supplement token is $4.99.
Questions
A full review: a score out of 100, a note on every sentence, the paragraph costing you most and a 10-point draft check, in 5–10 minutes. We never write a word of your essay.
Review my essay →Keep reading
More in Supplements and UC
All guides by topic →- Supplemental essays: what they are and how to plan them3 min
- How to write the "Why this college?" essay2 min
- UC Personal Insight Questions: how to choose and answer them2 min
- How to write the diversity essay3 min
- How to write the "Why this major?" essay5 min
- How to write the extracurricular activity essay4 min
- How to write a scholarship essay4 min
- College short answer questions: how to make 25 to 150 words count3 min
- How to write a college transfer essay3 min
- Can you change your UC application after you submit it?5 min
- Supplemental essay word limits: how long each college's essays are in 2026-276 min
- Colleges without supplemental essays in 2026-27: a checked list4 min
- UC PIQ 1: how to answer the leadership question6 min
- UC PIQ 8: what makes you a strong candidate for the University of California6 min
- UC PIQ 2: how to answer the creative side question6 min
- UC PIQ 3: how to answer the greatest talent or skill question5 min
- UC PIQ 4: how to answer the educational opportunity or barrier question6 min
- UC PIQ 5: how to answer the significant challenge question6 min
- UC PIQ 6: how to answer the academic subject that inspires you6 min
- UC PIQ 7: how to answer the make your community better question5 min
- Colleges with a "why us" supplemental essay in 2026-27: the list and the word limits5 min
- Community supplemental essays in 2026-27: 16 questions at 14 colleges4 min
- "What excites you" supplemental essays in 2026-27: 21 questions at 17 colleges4 min
- Optional supplemental essays in 2026-27: which of 40 colleges let you skip, and how to decide4 min
- Creative and unusual supplemental essay prompts in 2026-27: 15 questions at 9 colleges4 min
- "Tell us about an activity" supplemental essays in 2026-27: 7 questions at 7 colleges4 min